Def Leppard's Steve Clark and Phil Collen
Interview by: John Stix
Widely regarded by hard rock musicians as perhaps the most
perfect recording since the Boston album of '77, Def Leppard's Pyromania (1983) set
awesome standards as well as expectations for the band. Leppard may have rewritten the
Heavy Metal Rules book of '83, opened the gateway to a slew of Bon Jovi bashers, but by
'85 or so the notoriously discerning fans of crunching guitars wold know if they were real
or just another flash in the pan.
While metal itself was reeling from assorted body blows in '84 and '85, a double right
cross from MTV, a kidney chop from the PMRC, the boys of Def Leppard were getting their
backs bounced to the canvas, mired in troubles of their own. When Mutt Lange, their guru
for Pyromania, wasn't available, they tried to work with Jim Steinman of Meatloaf fame.
When that proved unsuccessful, they tried to produce themselves. Then on New year's Day,
1985, drummer Rick Allen lost his left arm in a car accident. For a band with two albums
in the can before Pyromania, this was a particularly vicious case of the Sophomore Jinx.
Summoning reserves of courage and expertise, the Leps survived, inspired by Rick
Allen's gutty return. And by waiting out the fates and the muses, and Mutt Lange's crowded
schedule, they managed to catch a break at last. Bouyed by the mega-success of
post-Leppard bands like Bon Jovi and Whitesnake, Poison and Cinderella, Hysteria's
eventual release arrived with what must be considered great timing.
It not as definitive a statement as Pyromania, Hysteria nonetheless answered many of
the burning hard rock questions turned to cinders during the hiatus. We had questions of
our own, perhaps the most burning of which was would guitarists Steve Clark and Phil
Collen cling to the energy of their youth, or instead stand up as musicians who were, like
it or not, four years older than those wile pyromaniacs who started metal blazing up the
charts when last we heard from them? The answer, as we learned in this interview, is that
time marched on and so did they.
After Pyromania fever died down did you put your guitars away?
STEVE: People don't realize that for the whole three and half year period
after Pyromania there was always at least one member of the group in the studio. There was
never a break. After we left America we went back to Europe and toured for another two
months.
PHIL: We finished touring and went straight to
Ireland and threw ourselves into writing. We had no material prepared whatsoever. At first
it was a struggle because we hadn't actually counted on the fact that the tour would end
and we'd have to write a new album. We didn't write any songs while we were on the tour.
So we were stuck. It was a bit uninspiring actually.
STEVE: We were a bit lost for a direction to take.
Was there anything from when Jim Steinman tried to produce the band that learned and later applied to the album?
PHIL: No. It didn't work at all. It was a very wrong move on our part. We
ended up having to scrap all of that and record again.
STEVE: The first two year were virtually fruitless.
Phil and I both knew exactly what we wanted and we couldn't get it. I don't think he heard
it the same way as we heard it. It wasn't going anywhere. We knew in our guts it was wrong
but we sort of went along. I think after Jim left about five new songs appeared.
Did any of those early efforts make Hysteria?
STEVE: "Gods of War" came out then.
PHIL: "Animal" is a reincarnation of the
original.
STEVE: We wrote "Armageddon it" in Dublin
and there's not one section that survived. The chorus wasn't strong enough so we changed
the chorus. Then we thought the chorus is so strong the verse is a bit weak. We rewrote
the verse and said the bridge stinks. There's not one excising note from the original, but
the progression that went over about three years.
PHIL: The only thing the same is it's still in E.
This is the first album where Phil had a hand in writing. Where is that influence heard most prominently?
STEVE: It's all throughout the record. Phil came up with a lot of lyrics.
I didn't come up with any lyrics on this album. Listen to the riff in "Rocket."
PHIL: We're not a band that says, you're the
guitarist, you write the music; you're the singer, come up with the lyrics. If anyone has
an idea then that's fine and good. I wrote vocal melodies as well. Instead of writing a
guitar riff and putting the melody on top of it, I'd write a melody and we'd put chords
underneath.
STEVE: We'd guitarize it after, in the gaps between
the vocal, rather than coming up with a complicated riff and thinking, where is the vocal
going to go? We'd come up with the vocal first and in the gaps we'd be putting interesting
riffs and suspensions. That's something that Phil added that we'd never done before. The
good thing about it is we have the capacity to think differently. Phil will come up with a
riff that I'd never even think of. Also, we can come together as some point and make it
work.
What's the role of the guitar in the band's sound?
STEVE: We now approach things more like a classical orchestra. There is a
part for everybody to play. It might be the simplest thing in the world, but if it sets up
another part to come alive, that's what's right. It doesn't have to be difficult or
complicated, as long as it makes the song live. You just have to be mature about it. We
don't make bones about it, we do whatever it takes. People thought we were crazy sitting
in the studio just hitting an E string. Guys would come in and say what the hell are those
two doing? It can't be that simple, if it all comes together to make a piece of music work
that's the thing. It's just using the instrument properly.
PHIL: I wouldn't say we are making a detour, but
there's a lot of guitar players who play solos for the sake of self indulgent reasons. The
guitar, after all, is an instrument, and it should compliment others like a voice. If you
can't do that then you're playing wrong. If you're getting in the way of a song with a
great vocal, something is wrong.
If I spoke to you on the first album you probably wouldn't have this attitude.
STEVE: No, but it's a good sign that we have the capacity too grow, because I
know people who don't develop that. There are some great players around, but they are not
doing anything they weren't doing years ago. They are playing for themselves as an ego
trip. That's fine for them, but they're limiting their audience. We want to look beyond
just guitar players and cover every aspect. We take a lot of that is knowing when to stop.
PHIL: Another important factor that a lot of people
don't realize, is that so many good front room guitar players, when put in the studio with
a drum machine, can't play in time or they can't play chops. But you need to get it right.
We worked hard on this stuff. It improved our playing a hell of a lot.
STEVE: We play everything down to a click track. We
think if you can get dynamics and emotion out of the sounds and the playing itself, then
when you put the cymbals and drum fills on, it's going to add to it. We won't do that
until there is a certain amount of energy coming out of the guitars to a straight click.
Where a lot of other players bang it straight down to where there's no mistakes, we try to
get more out of it than that. This is a progression on the same way we did Pyromania. A
good example is "Love Bites," which has only two live rhythm guitars. We sat in
chairs playing harmonies and different suspensions to each other through two little
Gallien Kruegers. All we heard was a drum machine. We tried to go into the studio and
improve on the sounds but we couldn't get the same vibe. So even though we record some
songs very precisely, that we left as it was because we couldn't recreate it. It's very
difficult because you can be playing for months and you're still playing to a guitar
backing track that's so tight. When the thing starts taking shape and the backing vocals
appear and the bass goes on, that's when you sloppy it up a bit. That's when the track
comes to life, but you know you're playing to a solid foundation. If it starts wavering on
the backing track it's only going to get sloppier from there on. When the backing track is
rock solid it's the reverse, and things can get even better.
PHIL: A lot of the experimenting we did
individually. There were some things where we played live together. On the
"Rocket" solo we got the solo worked out and we played the same solo. We made it
purposely sloppy. But is was done first take.
STEVE: The actual backing track was so rigid that we
wanted to sloppy it up. The solos we played in unison and one out of 10 in harmony. I'd be
wanging it, bending it into tune. We'd have different spinoffs. I'd add a totally
different delay to what Phil was using. It created a wash in the solo. The solo in
"Hysteria" was done live.
PHIL: The rideout section on "Hysteria"
as well.
When you're so meticulous where is the spontaneous spirit of rock 'n' roll?
PHIL: An album is immortal. It lasts for a lifetime. A nights show comes and
goes, so you can be spontaneous. But you've really got to make sure the album is right.
STEVE: We definitely separate playing live from the
studio. It's two different approaches. There's all that atmosphere live. You're buzzed up,
there's a lot of people there. In the studio you're playing to four walls. You have to
create an atmosphere. In the control room we'd put the lights off and get moody.
PHIL: Live is a totally different thing. You expect
mistakes and to be sweaty and for your voice to out of tune and to bend notes out of tune
now and again. That's what makes it live.
STEVE: If you do it live exactly the way it is on
the record, that's the reverse. I'd have to put a Strat down and pick up a Les Paul for
the bridge and after the bridge, take the guitar off and play a Gretsch. Within the songs
themselves, some passages have four counter melodies going on underneath the vocal. That's
four different guitar parts. There's no way, between the two of us, that we can play that.
What we do is pick out the most featured parts and condense the two parts into one. It's
not cheating, but we don't try and get it exact. We pick out what people hear on the
record and play it. We do get it pretty close.
PHIL: What we lack from that is definitely made up for in
energy. During the five months the album took to mix we did some B sides and started
rehearsing. We rehearse until we can do it in our sleep. The main thing is when we started
rehearsing these songs they were physically impossible to do. We rehearsed so much we
actually got it. We raised our standard.
STEVE: The fun comes after we get it automatic
because you don't have to think about it too much. Then you can experiment and things
change nightly. On this tour we no have the ability to chop and change songs every night,
which we never did before. We rehearsed far more songs than we actually play. There is a
lot of contact, rather than saying it's like this on the record and that's it. It might be
totally different the night after that. We might not even play that song. We learned that
from Prince. It makes it exciting for us as well as the audience. I'm not the biggest
Prince fan in the world, but do like some of his stuff and the professional way he
presents a show. It's even down to the way he works to put a show together behind the
scenes. He keeps his crew in order and there's no drinking until after the show. We let a
lot of things go in the past. He taught us a lot from every aspect. Now we keep our eyes
open for everything.
PHIL: Prince rehearses his band nine hours a day
sometimes, even on a show day.
STEVE: We met him in a little jazz club in Paris. That's
the time he wasn't playing guitar anymore. Phil said, why don't you play more guitar?
Prince did a set in this 200 seater and he played "Red House" for Phil. Another
thing Prince showed us was that there's always a way to get around things. We were scared
to use a pedal board because it ties you down. What we learned from Prince was to get an
effects rack and let somebody else work the thing. It's a question of being more
professional and expecting more from your crew. It was the same philosophy with the album.
We said there is no way we can do this live. Now we actually play the new songs better
than the older songs. Even the way we present songs live, there's no battle between us.
We're not afraid for one of the guitars to drop out during a verse to create dynamics.
It's maturity. Mutt Lange made me aware of it too. You get a bit bored and want more than
just a three pick up Les Paul and a Marshall and that's it. Steve Stevens blew me away
with a great sound. The guy in Simple Minds got to me. It wasn't his playing so much as
some of the sounds he was getting. I woke up one day and thought I want to get into using
different delays and a chorus rather than just a Marshall.
PHIL: You kind of wake up and start listening to other
things. You become aware of dynamics. Sting and the Police had an impact on me. So did a
lot of the early Motown stuff. The recording techniques weren't that great but the
dynamics of the songs still come through. There is obviously more than just studio
technology and studio equipment. You know it's in the playing. It was something I learned,
especially from working with Mutt Lange. I wasn't aware of time. I never used to really
listen to what else was going on. I used to listen to only me and go wild, which is a very
selfish thing. After a while you listen to timing and what the drum parts are doing and
the bass and you play toward that, so your playing changes a bit.
STEVE: It's almost like one day you wake up and you are
aware. It comes with age, but it sort of dawned on us. For example when we played
"Love and Affection" live or "Armageddon it" I used the Firebird. I
don't need the loudest most distorted guitar. Phil is doing the solo, so I don't need that
much sustain. And it worked for the song. We realize now no matter how good the outfront
guy is who is doing the sound, he can only control what is coming off the stage. If we
nail that and get a clearer sound for the rhythm part so the solo shines through, it will
have a bit more clarity and it's a different ballgame out front.
Did you go through changes in equipment as well?
PHIL: A hell of a lot. Now I use Jacksons. Grover Jackson sent me Charvel
and it blew me away. I met Grover and he made me a Jackson Soloist with Jackson pickups
and a Kahler and I love it. He is building me a special shape body with a 24 fret neck.
STEVE: I endorse Gibson now. They made a lot of
changes for me. I have two brand new Les Pauls with Kahlers. I feel more relaxed about
playing now, so Gibson made me some coil taps so when I press the volume control the
pickups split. I wouldn't have felt comfortable doing that before. I'm also using
Firebirds, which have the weaker pickups, for songs like, "Too Late for Love"
and "Love and Affection." It's a compromise between a Strat and a Les Paul. It's
got that bite to it but more warmth than a Strat. Gibson made me one which has the treble
volume control push pot for splitting the coils.
PHIL: We both use the same amp setup. We're using
two Randall rack mounted heads in stereo with Randall cabs. We use two 4x12's and two
2x12's on each side where the mike stand is. There is one 2x12 at the back. We use t.c.
Electronics gear for chorus and delay, which our roadies operate. We'll try anything.
The kind of layers and dynamics I expect from Queen are all over Hysteria.
PHIL: We like that big sound. Although they did it with vocals we've done
it with guitars as well.
STEVE: After Pyromania, we said we never wanted to make
Pyromania II so it was a very intentional approach. There were more keyboards in
Pyromania, so we said, let's still write keyboard parts but play them on guitars. We even
tried to make the guitars sound like keyboards in some places. It's very orchestrated and
we try to get a lot of dynamics and clarity out by layering sounds.
Did you know what you were going after?
PHIL: We knew how it should sound and that we weren't getting close to it. A lot
of stuff took a hell of a lot of experimentation. We used E-bows, or played a whole chord
by playing each string individually. We tracked it eight times. Eventually we got what we
wanted.
STEVE: It was very hard work. There were times when we felt like throwing in the towel
and saying we're trying to get something that is impossible. But we just kept on trying.
Your musical approach sounds almost like Boston. If you were to pick out any melody note in the vocal along with the rest of what is going on, that single note would make an intentional chord?
STEVE: If you saw it on manuscript it would probably look that way. The thing is not to clutter things or to have conflicting melodies clashing with each other. We start off with a click and it takes a certain shape. Then you go in that direction for a song. We treat every song differently. We wanted the album to be a collection of songs; we didn't want it to be all straight down the line with the same guitar sounds or rehearsing the things we'd done before. "Excitable" is new territory for us to do.
Who did what solo?
STEVE: I did the solo on "Women" We both did "Rocket," "Animal" is Phil, "Shot Gun" and "Gods of War" is me. "Love and Affection" is Phil. "Sugar" doesn't have a solo in it.
Did fatigue set in during recording?
PHIL: That's one of Mutt's great points. He'll make you do it until it's right.
He'll sit till five in the morning.
STEVE: We were running out of time and it was
costing a lot of money. We said we've got to knuckle down and if you don't finish till
five in the morning than that's the time you finish.
Did you have a say in the mix?
STEVE: After Jim Steinman left we tried producing ourselves. We're a real democracy and nobody's ideas get shelved before they are tried. It takes us five times longer to do anything. Applying that same theory when doing the mix, there's five different pairs of ears. We all hear it differently. We said we'll be mixing this album for the next three years if we don't let someone take charge. We let Mutt mix it.
I love the instrumental part of "Women" with that last D chord.
STEVE: Itwasn't part of the song at all originally.
That developed in the studio. Basically we had half a song and then went in and totally
redid the end bit.
PHIL: Mutt said we need an ending on this song that's
different. We sat down and worked out a climactic bit. To be quite honest, the end is a
bit of a goof off left on.
STEVE: There's an E after the D which didn't make it.
PHIL: It's like the nonsense before "Rock of
Ages."
STEVE: We had the same thing with
"Photograph," there's a noise before the riff comes in. The rideout on
"Hysteria," with Phil on a clean sort of Tele sound was another accident. He
filled in every gap between the vocal. People will think that is the most clever thing
ever done. It was a total accident.
It sounds like this album is exactly as you want it to be.
STEVE: As close as we could get it at the time. I don't think we could have gotten it much better. The next time it could be totally different.